The reading for this blog entry is "Hunger of
Memory". It's an autobiography by Richard Rodriguez who came to the United
States as a child, who only spoke Spanish. The autobiography takes you through
his life, and his development. Initially, he thinks of the way his family
speaks in Spanish at home as a type of intimacy. Over the course of the reading,
as they all learn to speak English more fluently, his family life changes. They
go from a family who only felt they could communicate freely at home, to being
a family who is connected to the outside world. It changes the dynamic of their
relationships. Towards the end of the reading, he reaches a point where he
doesn't even really feel comfortable speaking Spanish at all. He uses the
example of his grandmother however, who only spoke Spanish to prove that their
intimacy didn't depend on language. He understood Spanish, so he would just listen
to her and nod a lot of the time, but they still had an intimate relationship.
He argues, "Bilingual enthusiasts, moreover, sin against intimacy."
These are the people who argue that people should keep their family language.
He claims that these people credit their language to what they should credit to
their family members. It’s the people who depend upon their language and think
that that's what keeps their family intimate. He disagrees, because he feels
like intimacy isn't about language. I think it's interesting because he's
someone who comes from Spanish as his first language and had to go through a
lot of difficulty in order to speak English, and he still doesn't agree with
it. It wasn't what I was expecting to come out of the reading, especially with how
it started out as him really appreciating that his home life had a different
language than most of the people around them. He felt that it bought them
closer. His argument shows both sides, because as a child, he seems to be a
bilingual enthusiast. However, as he grows up, his perspective changes.
I completely agree with Rachel, I was surprised by the main characters perspective by the end of the article. I thought he was going to say he grew away from his family when he grew away from his language, but in fact that is completely opposite of what he says. He says that language and relationships do not go hand in hand. This idea brought up a great perspective to notice.
ReplyDeleteI like how at the end you say "perspective changes" I think that has a big part on everyones life. Life changes by the perspectives you take
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Rachel. I thought it was so sad that by the end he wasn't comfortable anymore speaking Spanish and that he couldn't hear the sounds that he once heard before.
ReplyDelete